Clarke’s contract extension under fire after Scotland’s group exit

Scotland head coach Steve Clarke, who signed a four‑year contract extension before the Qatar World Cup, now faces scrutiny after his side finished third in Group C, beating Haiti 1‑0 but missing the knockout stage as only four of the twelve third‑place finishers advance. Scotland were drawn in a group that also contained Brazil and Morocco, who sit fifth and sixth in FIFA’s rankings – the only group with two top‑10 teams. The side was expected to finish third and did so after a 1‑0 win over Haiti. Only four of the twelve third‑place finishers progress, and Scotland’s campaign ended while Cape Verde, Ghana and Bosnia‑Herzegovina moved on, with DR Congo also expected to join the advancing pot‑four nations. Steve Clarke entered the tournament on a new four‑year contract, becoming Scotland’s longest‑serving manager with 81 matches in charge. The Scottish FA’s support grew after the nation’s participation in three of the last four major finals, and Scotland will co‑host Euro 2028 with England, Wales and the Republic of Ireland.

Can Ancelotti become the first Italian to lift the World Cup with Brazil?

Willie Miller, a former Scotland defender who played at the 1982 and 1986 World Cups, said, "Over the three games you're definitely looking at below‑par performances." He added that the lack of a top‑class striker was "a major issue" and expressed uncertainty about the logic of a few selections, while still backing Clarke. Former striker James McFadden criticised the defending, claiming it was "certainly below the standard we're used to and the errors were costly." He also suggested that Scotland could have earned two penalties and a red card against Morocco and that they "gave Brazil two gifts". Pat Nevin, who played alongside Clarke for Scotland and Chelsea, argued that the team needed to understand its limitations and called the manager "ultra defensive" despite selecting players such as Ben Gannon‑Doak, John McGinn, Scott McTominay and Lawrence Shankland. He said Clarke might contemplate leaving because of the criticism, but added that his love for the job would likely keep him in place. Stephen O'Donnell, who earned 26 caps under Clarke and featured in all three group games, noted that Scotland reached their first World Cup in 28 years and secured their first win since 1990 with the Haiti victory. He accepted the 4‑0 aggregate defeats to Brazil and Morocco, called the experience a progression, and highlighted that Cape Verde’s group is easier, offering momentum for the next generation.